Don’t Be a Health Club!

A New Regulatory Problem For Yoga

As yoga has become a mainstream practice and turned into a multi-billion dollar industry, many regulatory agencies have taken note and are regulating yoga. Both the IRS and state taxing authorities are auditing yoga studios over the classification of teachers as independent contractors, state education boards have sought to regulate yoga teaching programs as secondary education schools, local sales taxes are being imposed on yoga studios, and ASCAP is collecting royalties from studios for performing music during yoga classes.

There is a new regulatory concern that may affect yoga studios across the country. Almost all states have laws that regulate the health club, gym and spa industry (“Health Clubs”). Health Clubs have a history of using unfair membership agreements, engaging in deceptive trade practices, and going out of business (which has caused their members to lose their advance payments).

Consequently, most States have passed laws that regulate the agreements that Health Clubs require their members to sign and require Health Clubs to post bonds to protect members in case they go out of business.

These laws require that specific legal language must be contained within membership agreements. They also prevent certain kinds of provisions-such as waiving legal rights-from being included within membership agreements.

New York has sought to impose its Health Club laws on yoga studios. Since New York is seeking to regulate yoga studios as Health Clubs, there is a risk that this will spread to other states. We have seen this occur in other regulatory areas.

Regulation in New York

In New York, the Attorney General sent a letter to a yoga studio asserting that it was in violation of the New York Health Club Services Law (the “Law”).  The Law defines a “health club” as a business offering instruction or facilities for the development of “physical fitness or well being.” The Attorney General took the position that the yoga studio was a “health club” within the meaning of the Law. As a “health club,” its membership agreement must comply with the requirements of the Law.

These requirements are: (i) posting a bond in case the Health Club goes out of business; (ii) including language in a membership agreement that paying the full amount in one payment is risky, (iii) giving members the right to cancel their agreement for a three day period; (iv) requiring that certain language be in bold face type; and (v) prohibiting provisions that waive a member’s legal rights.

There are civil penalties of $2500 for each violation.

If a “health club” loses it case before the Attorney General, it must also send a notice to its members that it has revised its agreement to comply with the Law and that the new agreement will be in effect in the future.

My Argument to the Attorney General

The Attorney General of New York permitted me to file a brief that argued yoga studios are exempt from the Law.  I am happy to report that the Attorney General was convinced by my brief and we won the case. However, it is important to note that this decision was based on the specific facts concerning the business of this studio. Other studios with different business models in New York may violate the Law. Also, studios located in other states may also be in violation of the local Health Club laws.

I have outlined the arguments that I made to the Attorney General below. I am providing this so you will have some insight into how you might present your case if you are contacted by the Attorney General in your home state. Naturally, you should hire a lawyer, but this should give you a head start on building your case!

Here is my argument:

1. I defined “yoga” as a spiritual rather than a physical practice. I relied upon the Yoga Sutras as authority. In Yoga Sutra 1.2, Patanjali defined yoga as the cessation of the fluctuations of the mind. Yoga Sutra 1.3 says that, when the mind becomes still, one becomes unified with the true Self. Thus, the principal concern of yoga is the transformation of consciousness. It is not physical fitness. I observed that, out of the 196 Yoga Sutras, only three referred to a physical practice. I also noted that “asana” (the basis for physical movement in classical yoga) refers to “seat” within the context of a meditation practice.

I quoted Dr. David Frawley, Nayaswami Gyandev McCord and Swami Ramananda who are included in the discussion of yoga on the Yoga Alliance website. All of these experts view yoga as a spiritual discipline to strengthen the point.

2. I compared my definition of yoga with quotations from the offerings of several gyms, health clubs and spas in New York City which all emphasize physical training, physical fitness and sports. This yoga studio does not offer the same types of classes or services as gyms, health clubs and spas

3. The Law defines a “health club” as a business offering instruction or facilities for the development of “physical fitness or well being.” This includes such businesses as health spas, sports, tennis, figure salons, health studios, gymnasiums, weight control studios, martial and “any other similar course of physical training.” By definition, a yoga studio is not within the list of businesses that are “health clubs.” I did make some technical arguments to show that this yoga studio is not in the business of developing “well being.”

Based upon my definition of yoga as a spiritual discipline, I argued that yoga studios are not “health clubs” within the meaning of the Law.

4. I  found surveys of the Health Club industry that the Attorney General and the City of New York had conducted. None of these surveys included any yoga studios. This made it clear that, based on precedent, they did not consider yoga studios to be Health Clubs. The New York State Department of Taxation and Finance also published some rulings that did not include yoga studios within the definition of Health Clubs.

5.  Based on an analysis of the Law, defining yoga as a spiritual rather than a physical practice and relying upon precedent, I concluded that the yoga studio did not violate the Law because it is not a “health club” nor does it enter into “contracts for services” within the meaning of the Law.

I want to emphasize that this studio is small and devotional. It does not offer any hot yoga, power classes, spinning classes, pilates or other classes that emphasize the fitness side of yoga. It is not a combination of a yoga studio and a gym.  If your studio has these types of offerings, it would be much harder to argue that you are not a “health club”.  Of course, this will depend upon the laws of the state where your studio is located.

Action Item

I recommend that you run  a search in your home state to see if it has any Health Club laws. The search can be as follows:  “_______ (name of your state) health club regulation.”

If you state does not regulate Health Clubs, then you are in luck.

However, if your state does regulate Health Clubs, they you can either (i) hire a lawyer to advise you if you are subject to the laws; or (ii) read the law and make your own determination.

The benefit to using the lawyer is that he or she can advise you if your studio is covered by the law. If you are covered, you will need the lawyer to amend your membership agreement so that it contains the required language and complies with the law. If you are not covered, then you do not need to do anything at all.

If you decide to make your own determination, take the most conservative view. You may find that the law is ambiguous as to whether you are covered or not. In that case, the safest approach is to comply with the law. It may be fairly simple to include the required provisions in your membership agreement and they are designed to protect your members anyway.

Light on Law Newsletter

Please sign up for my Light on Law newsletter so you can keep on top of current legal issues in the yoga and wellness world. Please click here to subscribe:

http://tinyurl.com/clakwyn

Light on Law Books and Other Resources

My Light on Law series of books provide yoga studios and teachers with everything they need to know about the law and yoga. These books also include large collections of legal templates. For information about these books and my other offerings, please visit my website:

http://garykissiah.com/#top

So You Want To Buy or Sell a Yoga Studio? What You Should Know!

As the yoga world has expanded, I have seen an increase in purchases and sales of yoga and wellness studios.

Some owners want to sell their studios because they are moving, their interests have changed, or running a yoga studio proves to be a much harder and stressful business than they imagined. Also, as the number of yoga studios has increased, so have competitive pressures and conflicts between yoga studios.

On the other hand, others are interested in purchasing existing studios. They fall in love with the practice or the lifestyle, or want to dedicate themselves to service through yoga.

Their are many advantages to buying a pre-existing studio. The new owners can step  into a lease, and acquire pre-existing relationships with a student and teacher community. The yoga supplies and office equipment have been purchased, the studio has been built out and software systems such as Mind Body have been set up. Many owners view buying an up and running business as being easier than building a business from scratch. Of course, it is not all unicorns and rainbows, and there are many potential problems that may arise from buying an existing business.

What are the legal and business issues that both buyers and sellers should consider? Be mindful that the interests of a buyer and a seller are very different. The seller wants to receive the highest price and the avoidance of future liabilities coming from the studio. The buyer wants to pay the lowest price and for the seller to protect the buyer from future liability. This article will present both sides of the discussion.

1. Asset or Stock Sale?

The first issue is whether the sale will be an asset sale or a stock sale. If the transaction is an asset sale, then the seller is selling a specific list of assets of the business. The liabilities are not sold with the business, and the seller remains responsible for the liabilities. In some cases, the seller may retain a few specific assets or transfer certain liabilities if the buyer agrees. If the seller owns the business through a legal entity such as a corporation or a limited liability company (“LLC”), the seller will keep ownership of the entity. It will not be transferred to the buyer.

If the transaction is a stock sale, the legal entity that owns the studio is sold to the buyer. If a corporation owns the studio, all of the shares of corporate stock will be sold to the buyer. If a LLC owns the studio, all of the membership interests in the LLC will be transferred to the buyer. It is possible for the seller to retain shares of stock or membership interests such that the seller becomes a minority owner after the transaction, but this structure would be rare in the yoga world.

In a stock sale, the buyer takes the entire business. This means that the buyer purchases all of the assets and liabilities of the business. The seller would not be responsible for the liabilities of the business after the sale closes.

This decision can involve complicated tax, accounting and legal issues. I recommend that you consult with your accountant or lawyer in making this decision.

2. What Are The Assets and Liabilities?

Under either structure, it is important that the seller is able to accurately account for all of the assets and liabilities of the business.

A list of all assets being sold must be prepared so that they can be legally transferred to the buyer. Assets include the yoga props and equipment, office furniture, studio art, boutique merchandise, other tangible assets, accounts receivable, customer and student lists, website and domain names, social media accounts, cash, and intangible assets such as intellectual property and goodwill.

All of the liabilities must be understood so that they will be either conveyed to the buyer or retained by the seller. Liabilities include such items as the lease, promissory notes, account indebtedness, contingent liabilities, tax liabilities, employee or independent contractor liabilities, and contractual obligations and liabilities. Any contingent liabilities such as lawsuits or tax audits must also be identified.

This shows that it is important that all yoga studios keep accurate accounting records. It will help you keep your taxes straight and will be important if you ever decide to sell your studio.

3. The Letter of Intent

I recommend that the buyer and seller prepare a letter of intent. This is a simple letter agreement which sets forth the important points about the proposed sale of the business. It is written in plain English, and does not contain legal language. It is designed to help both parties identify, discuss and resolve all of the issues.

Here are the points that the letter of intent should cover:

a. Is the sale an asset sale or a stock sale?

b. If it is an asset sale, what are the assets of the business? Are any assets being excluded from the sale?

c. If it is a stock sale, what type of legal entity does the seller own? Is it a corporation or a LLC? What State is it organized in, and how many stockholders or members does it have? How many shares or membership interests are issued and outstanding? How many shareholders or members does it have? Is it in good standing in the State where it was organized? Has it filed all of its federal and state tax returns?

d. What are the liabilities of the business? Is the seller retaining any liabilities (under either structure)?

e. What is the purchase price of the business?

Valuation of small businesses is very difficult because there are few comparable sales that can be used as guidance. It is “fuzzy math.” Generally, the calculation is based on net cash flow. This could be 100% of net cash flow or a multiple of net cash flow. Net cash flow is usually averaged over a several year period.

There is also a component of goodwill in valuing a small business. This is an intangible asset (as distinct from a tangible or physical asset), but it does have value in a sale. Goodwill could be the brand name of the studio, the reputation of the owners, the value of the yoga community, the length of time that the studio has been in business and similar factors.

Another method is an asset-based valuation. This is a straightforward method in which the value of the business is determined by the total value of the company’s tangible and intangible assets.

The amount of the lease payments should also be considered because it is a significant liability that the buyer is assuming.

I have done transactions in which the price was based on the fair market value of the studio’s physical assets plus a small amount for the goodwill. The seller was primarily interested in transferring responsibility of the lease to the buyer.

f. How Is the Purchase Price Paid?

There a few options: all cash, cash and a promissory note, and cash and an earn-out.

Sometimes the buyer cannot afford to write a check for the full purchase price of the business. Sometimes the buyer pays a portion of the price in cash and the balance in a promissory note. The note should be secured by the assets of the business.

Cash with an earn-out means that the buyer makes an upfront cash payment and then pays the seller the balance of the purchase price by giving the seller a percent of free cash flow or a royalty payment each year. That way the buyer pays the purchase price over time.

g. Post-Closing Duties of Seller

Is the seller willing to help the buyer with the business after closing the sale?  Is the seller willing to help transfer the business in an efficient and elegant way? This could mean participating in an announcement to the student community and working with the teachers to help them feel comfortable with a change in ownership. It may also mean that the seller is willing to be available for a certain period of time to teach the buyer about running the business. The duties of the seller, if any, should be described.

h. Consents

What consents are need to sell the business? The consent of the landlord to assign the lease will almost certainly be required. There may be a need to amend business permits to reflect the change in ownership. These permits are usually issued by the city or county where the business is located. If there are other stockholders and members who are owners in the business, their consent would be required.

i. Due Diligence

The buyer should have the right to examine all of the books and records of the business. This helps the buyer understand the profitability of the business, and all of the assets and liabilities that it may be assuming, and will have effect the purchase price.

j. Non-Disclosure Agreement

A non-disclosure agreement  (“NDA”) is usually signed before the seller gives the buyer the books and records of the business for due diligence purposes.

k. Public Announcements

When will public announcements be made about the sale? Who will make the announcement? What will it say? Will the seller participate in the announcement?

Parties should discuss how to manage the yoga teachers and studio staff. The sale of the business may be quite stressful to the teachers and staff, so it may be a good idea to hold a meeting to answer questions.

l. Expenses

Who will pay the closing expenses? Usually each party pays for its own expenses, including lawyers and accountants. Sometimes legal fees are split between the parties because it may be unfair for one party to pay all of the legal fees.

m. Closing Day

When and where will the closing occur? What documents need to be signed and exchanged?

n. The Purchase Agreement and Other Documents

The parties should agree to work together in good faith to negotiate and sign a purchase agreement, and any other documents that may be needed for the sale to close. Other documents may include a bill of sale, a domain purchase agreement, an assignment of intellectual property,  and a promissory note (if part of the deal).

4. The Lease

The lease is one of the most important issues in the sale of a yoga studio. It is one of the biggest expenses of running the business, and the consent of the landlord is needed to assign the lease.

Landlords often take this as an opportunity to raise the rent or impose other conditions before they will give their consent to transferring the lease to the buyer.

Be aware that the seller may remain obligated on the lease even though it has been transferred to the buyer. This means that, if the buyer defaults in payment of the lease, then the seller becomes liable.

It is a good idea for the buyer to ask the seller to get an estoppel letter from the landlord. This letter states that the seller is not in default under the lease and that the lease is in full force and effect. This will prevent the landlord from making the buyer pay for problems that the seller caused under the lease.

The return of the seller’s security deposit should also be discussed.

It is common for the buyer to ask the landlord to build out or modify the space. If this is the case, a letter agreement should be signed between the landlord and the buyer. It is important that a deadline be included in the letter. I know of situations where the landlord has delayed opening the studio because they were in no hurry to get the construction work done. I have also seen disputes over who pays for the buildout when unforeseen problems arise.

5. Allocation of Purchase Price

When selling business assets, the federal tax rate on gains can vary from 15% (long-term capital gain) to 35% (ordinary income rates). Seller and buyer should reach an agreement on the allocation of the total purchase price to the assets acquired. Guidance from an accountant is necessary to properly allocate the purchase price.

6. The Purchase Agreement

The purchase agreement is the primary document that governs the sale of the business. If it is an asset transaction, it is called an asset purchase agreement. If it is a stock transaction, it is called a stock purchase agreement.

The purchase agreement should be prepared by a lawyer. There are too many legal and business issues involved in the sale of a business to handle without a lawyer.

Here is an overview of the main sections contained within a standard asset purchase agreement:

a. Description of assets to be purchased.

This includes tangible and intangible assets. Tangible assets are physical assets such as bolsters and mats. Intangible assets are intellectual property and good will. If the studio is selling teacher training manuals or trademarks, then an intellectual property assignment needs to be used.

If social media accounts and domain names are to be sold, these should be described and legal mechanisms to transfer these assets should be included within the agreement.

b. The purchase price.

As discussed above, how is the purchase price to be paid?

c.  Excluded liabilities.

These are liabilities that are kept by the seller. These may include general liabilities (i.e., any liability of seller either known or unknown), debts, taxes, violations of law, contractual liabilities, employee liabilities and litigation.

The employee liabilities are important. These include any liabilities relating to present and past employees of the business. These could include employee benefits, liabilities arising under employment agreements, or any liabilities associated with mischaracterizing the employees of the business as independent contractors. These may include: (i) liability for workers’ compensation; or (ii) liability for benefits earned by any employees prior to the closing date; or (iii) any federal, state or local back taxes, penalties and interest.

What happens if a studio is audited after the sale takes place but the audit period covers the period before the sale? Because the IRS and many state taxing authorities are auditing yoga studios over mischaracterizing their teachers as independent contractors  (rather than as employees), this may be an important liability that should be discussed.The buyer may end up having to manage an audit and pay the tax bill if the buyer loses the audit, even though the misclassification occurred during the time that the seller owned the studio.

The seller should reimburse the buyer for these liabilities. What if the seller does not have any money, has moved away or cannot be found?

d. Allocation of purchase price.

As discussed above, buyer and seller should agree upon the allocation of the purchase price with the guidance of their accountants.

e. Right of the buyer to conduct due diligence into the books and records of the business.

f. The date and time of closing.

g. Conduct of business in normal course.

Before the closing date, the seller should operate the business in the normal course. This means that the seller should not do anything out of the ordinary with respect to the business.

h. Lease

The issues concerning the lease as discussed above must be addressed. It is usually a condition to closing that the landlord consent to assignment of the lease. This means that, if the landlord does not consent to assignment of the lease to the buyer, then the buyer does not have to go forward and buy the studio.

i. Representations and Warranties.

The seller must make several representations about the condition of the business. If these representations turn out to be wrong, it must reimburse (or indemnify) the buyer if the buyer suffers a loss.

These representations usually cover: title to the assets, operation of the business in compliance with laws, the condition of the physical assets, and that the sale of the business will not violate any contract to which the seller may be bound.

j. Closing Procedures

The agreement contains a section about closing procedures. These are delivery of the purchase price against a bill of sale of the assets, the assignment of the lease, the consent of the landlord, delivery of any promissory notes, and other similar matters.

k. Indemnity

The agreement should contain a section under which the seller will indemnify the buyer if any of its representations are wrong. Indemnity means that, if the buyer suffers any damages, losses or expenses as a result of the seller’s wrongful representations or other actions of the seller, then the seller has to reimburse the buyer for its losses. The indemnity may also include covering the buyer for any tax liabilities for misclassification of workers during the period that the seller owned the business.

Lawyers often engage in complex discussions around indemnity. The seller wants it to be as narrow as possible. The seller seeks to make it expire in a short period of time, to put a ceiling on the amount of damages that the seller may need to pay and limit the scope of the section. The buyer, on the other hand, wants to do the opposite!

L.Confidentiality

The agreement will provide that its provisions are confidential and that neither side can disclose the terms of the transaction.

M.Bill of Sale

The agreement will include a bill of sale. The purpose of the bill of sale is to legally transfer title to the assets from the seller to the buyer.

N. Stock Purchase Agreements.

A stock purchase agreement is similar to an asset purchase agreement, except there are many representations and warranties made by the corporate entity that is being purchased.

Comprehensive lists of assets and liabilities are also made because the buyer will be assuming everything. There are also provisions that govern the transfer of the stock or membership interests, as the case may be.

7. Post Closing Covenants

The parties may agree to post closing covenants. These could include such things as working together on allocation of the purchase price, the seller’s support of the business during a transition period, a covenant not to compete, and payment of the buyer’s promissory note over time.

8. The Closing

Most closings for the purchase and sale of yoga studios are fairly simple. The parties will have already signed the purchase agreement so all of procedures for the closing will have been discussed and finalized.

At the closing, all of the related agreements will have been prepared. These may include the bill of sale, the promissory note, intellectual property assignment agreements, agreements to transfer domains and websites, assignment of the lease, landlord’s consent and any other agreements.

The purchase price is paid, all documents are signed and exchanged, hands are shaken, and the deal is done!

Conclusion

I hope I have given you some insights into some of the issues that are involved in the purchase and sale of a yoga studio. This is just a brief summary of the many issues that may be involved and there are many nuances to all of these issues. There perspective of the buyer and the seller on most of these issues is very different. As you can see, there is much to consider with respect to the purchase and sale of a yoga studio. It will be important to get the guidance of accountants and lawyers to handle business sales in a competent, fair and professional way.

Light on Law Newsletter

Please sign up for my Light on Law newsletter so you can keep on top of current legal issues in the yoga and wellness world. Please click here:

http://tinyurl.com/clakwyn

Resources

I have prepared sample asset purchase agreements and stock purchase agreements, together with additional resources. If you are interested in purchasing these agreements, please click here:

http://garykissiah.com/legal-agreements/

For more information about me and my other activities, please visit my website:

http://garykissiah.com/#top

Get A Social Media Policy Now!

If your yoga or wellness business has employees and if you are using social media or email to market your business, then you need to establish a social media policy to address a number of important legal and business issues.

Many companies encourage their employees to establish social media accounts and to directly engage with customers. Employees may publish blog articles, post photographs on Instagram or Facebook, and write articles for a wide number of social media platforms.  Most studios use newsletters to announce classes, retreats, yoga challenges, workshops, contests and other news. Many use employees to manage their social media platforms.

In other companies, employees mix business and personal use of social media. Employees may discuss management, staff, products and other matters relating to the company on their social media platforms. In both cases, a lack of guidance on the basic rules of proper communication may result in damage to a company’s reputation, loss of business, copyright infringement actions, and termination of employees. Many of these problems can be avoided by establishing social media policies.

All yoga studios and wellness businesses should adopt a social media policy. Social media policies are just as necessary as discrimination, leave, and vacation policies.

Why is this so? There are four main reasons.

Four Reasons Why You Need A Social Media Policy

1. To Protect Your Business Reputation

A social media policy is a guideline for employees to follow when they post about your company on social media networks. Even the best intentioned employee may need guidance on whether he or she should publish certain posts about your company. If an employee publishes a post that is damaging to your company’s reputation, it cannot be taken back. It will remain on the Internet for a very long time. If you employees know the rules and what is expected from them, they are less likely to make mistakes that cannot be fixed.

A social media policy is an opportunity to state clearly what standards of communication you expect.

2. To Educate Employees About Legal Issues

Generally, employers have the right to monitor their employees’ use of the Internet (including social media accounts, e-mails, and instant messaging) on corporate computers during employees’ on-duty hours. Employees need to understand that they have no right of privacy with respect to the social media posts that they make during the scope of their employment.

Employees must understand that corporate policies on anti-harassment, ethics and loyalty extend to social media both inside and outside the workplace. If an employee attacks or defames the company or harasses other employees online, it can lead to serious consequences work.

Employees need to understand that they cannot post trade secrets, proprietary information, or content that infringes the intellectual property belonging to another person.

For example, Getty Images has been very aggressive about finding unauthorized uses of its images in blog posts by yoga studios. The result is a demand letter and a legal obligation to pay a license fee and damages. This can lead to a bill of hundreds or thousands of dollars.

3. To Raise Awareness About Your Brand.

A social media policy can encourage your employees to post in positive ways that can enhance your brand. Rather than being a list of prohibitions, a social media policy can inspire your employees to help you meet your business goals. It can make sure that your employees are in alignment with the marketing goals and values of your company.

A social media policy can require that employees follow the company’s branding guidelines. These guidelines may govern the use of logos, trademarks, color schemes, or style guides.

A social media policy can educate your employees on how to talk about your business. What words do you use to describe your company and its business? Are there particular values or principles that you want associated with your business? On the other hand, are there things that you do not want associated with your business?

4. To Establish Ownership of Your Social Media Accounts

A social media policy can establish that the company, rather than its employees, own the social media accounts and the followers. It is becoming common for disputes between companies and employees to develop over ownership of social media accounts when an employee leaves the business. This is because employees may have spent significant time building up the social media platforms and may  feel that they should own the accounts. 

Ten Benefits of a Social Media Policy

If you are inspired to adopt a social media policy, then what are the areas that a good social medial policy should cover? What are the benefits to having a social media policy?

Here are ten key issues to consider:

1. It creates a safe process and communication path for employees to share their concerns and problems at the office with management before taking them online. It is much better to solve personnel problems in-house on a confidential basis, rather than exposing them online.

2. It establishes what the company considers confidential information that may not be discussed publicly or posted online. It clearly describes when employees need approval before posting certain types of information. This could include corporate trade secrets, financial information, business plans, documents subject to non-disclosure agreements, content that may infringe intellectual property rights, and similar matters.

3. It establishes clear consequences of an employee’s online behavior. This gives the employee fair notice of the standard of behavior that the company expects, and will put the company in a stronger position if it needs to discipline or terminate an employee for improper posting.

4. It appoints a company spokesperson who is responsible for answering questions about your company on social media or to the press. Employees should have a clear understanding of those sensitive areas they should not discuss or comment on. They should be required to refer them to a company spokesman.

5. It establishes the proper way for employees to engage with others online, especially in those situations that are inflammatory, hostile or potentially damaging to the company’s business. The policy should encourage employees to be polite and agree to disagree with others, especially on Facebook, and Twitter where disputes can go viral very quickly.

6. It discusses illegal conduct. This involves educating employees about the proper use of trademarks and publication of copyrighted material. Posts that comment on legal matters or that are beyond the poster’s expertise should not be published. Misleading or inaccurate information should not be posted. Confidential information and trade secrets should not be posted.

7. It reflects the company’s culture and shows employees how to talk about its culture and values in a positive and honest way. Your social media policy is a great place to articulate your company’s culture and values. Since the conversation between companies, employees and their customers has moved to the Internet and social media, it is important for companies to extend their communications policies to include the Internet.

8. It educates and trains employees about their social media responsibilities. This can go a long way in getting people to think about the content of their post and the potential reactions to their post, before they click “send.”

9. As more companies recognize the brand value created through social media platforms, there is greater interest in owning corporate social media accounts and retaining the follower base that builds up over time. However, because many employees use social media accounts at work, they may believe that the accounts they use during work hours are not company property but are their own personal property. 

If the company wants to own the social media accounts and prevent conflicts with employees over ownership of the accounts, the social media policy will establish company ownership.

10. It shows employees how to respond when they make a mistake in a post. The employee should be the first to respond to the mistake. The employee should be up front about the mistake and correct it quickly to restore trust. If it is necessary to correct the content, such as by editing a blog post, the employee should make it clear that it has done so.

Terminating Employees For Posting Negative Information  About Your Company

The right of employees to post information about their employment is protected by federal law. This means that you, in many cases, cannot fire an employee for posting hostile, negative, critical and even obscene information about you or your company.

Some states, including California, Colorado, Connecticut, North Dakota and New York, have laws that prohibit employers from disciplining an employee based on off-duty publications on social media platform, unless they can be shown to damage the company in some way. There are also federal laws that restrict employers in the same way.

In 1935, Congress enacted the National Labor Relations Act (“NLRA”) to protect the rights of employees and employers.  The NLRA is administered by the National Labor Relations Board (the “Board”).

Under the NLRA, employers may not discipline employees for comments made on social media platforms regarding their employment, unless the employee’s behavior is so outrageous that it loses the protection of the NLRA. 

What is the boundary line of permissible behavior by employees before they lose the protection of the NLRA?

The Board has ruled on several cases and its General Counsel has issued several Memos to provide guidance. In general, these statements balance the right for an employee to publish employment-related speech on social media platforms as protected speech under the NLRA against the employer’s right to protect its business reputation.

Employers must consider disciplining employees for social media communications very carefully. Because the law is rapidly evolving,  employers cannot rely on their common sense judgment alone to guide them; they should get legal guidance before taking any action against an employee for his or her behavior on social media.

Here is where you can get additional information about the NLRB:

https://www.nlrb.gov/news-outreach/news-story/acting-general-counsel-issues-second-social-media-report

https://www.nlrb.gov/news-outreach/fact-sheets/nlrb-and-social-media

Samples of Good Social Media Policies

The Gap and TNT are considered to have very good social media polices. Here are the links:

http://groundfloormedia.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2012/03/Socialmedia@gap.pdf

https://www.tnt.com/content/dam/corporate/pdfs/Archive/Presentations/2014/tnt_social_media_employee-guidelines_2014en.pdf

Additional Resources on Social Media

I have prepared a comprehensive package of materials on social media policies. This package contains Social Media Guidelines prepared for yoga studios, a Code of Conduct for yoga teachers (which may be included within the Social Media Guidelines), guidance on how you can make sure you own the social media accounts you are using for your business, guidance on how to draft a legal social media policy under the NLRA, and resources on social media policies and best practices.

The package is a PDF and the documents may be copied and pasted into Word or other word processing program. These materials are available for purchase for $10.00. Click on this link if you want to purchase this package:

http://garykissiah.com/legal-agreements/

,

California Attacks Yoga Studios Over Taxes!

I am writing to let you know of an important and disturbing development that is threatening the yoga community in California.

The Threat To Your Yoga Studio

The California Economic Development Department (the “EDD”) has been aggressively targeting yoga studios in California to determine whether they have properly classified yoga teachers and other workers as independent contractors rather than as employees. The EDD targets industries that are abusing the tax laws, audits and forces re-classification of workers from independent contractors to employees. The EDD may have set its sights on the yoga industry in California.

I know of eight studios that are being audited in the Bay Area alone. I know of several more which are under audit in Southern California. Although some audits are ongoing, substantial fines have been imposed against yoga studios. I do not know of any studios that have won their audits. If you hear of any audits in your area, please let me know.

The EDD has an agreement with the IRS where they share information about companies that have misclassified their workers. If a studio is audited by the EDD, it may be audited again by the IRS. I have seen this in other States.

If you are audited and lose, you will pay back taxes and penalties. You may be forced to change your business model to employer-employee and your cost of doing business will increase. Your relationship with your teachers will change. You must comply with a large body of employment and tax laws.

Penalties For Misclassification

If you misclassify your workers and lose your audit, you may be liable for state unemployment taxes, worker’s compensation insurance, unpaid payroll taxes, penalties and interest. The EDD can look back three years. If you are audited by the IRS and lose, you may be liable for federal tax withholding, FICA and Medicare payments, federal unemployment, penalties and interest. In 2012, California passed a new independent contractor law. It imposes harsh civil penalties. For each violation, you may face a penalty of between $5,000 and $15,000 in addition to back taxes and other penalties. These may increase if there is a “pattern or practice” of violations.

What Can Yoga Studios Do?

You have three choices:

1. Do nothing and hope you do not get audited.

This is an unwise strategy. Your chances of being audited have now increased. If a studio in your town has been audited and converts to employer-employee, it may report your studio to the EDD because it is at a competitive disadvantage. Audits have been triggered when workers have mistakenly filed for unemployment compensation. The EDD randomly audits businesses. If you do nothing and are audited, you may be following business practices that may cause you to lose your audit.

2. Build Your Case That Your Teachers Are Independent Contractors

Take a very conservative position on classifying your workers as independent contractors and build the strongest legal case to defend yourself. The basic steps are to research and understand the law, complete the IRS and California independent contractor worksheets to assess whether you have properly classified your workers, change your business practices, use professional independent contractor agreements and avoid red flags.

The law in this area is too complex to discuss in this letter but the key legal test is control. The more you control your teachers, the greater the chance they are employees. The less you control your teachers, the greater the chance they are independent contractors.

You should consult with your tax expert, accountant or employment lawyer to get professional guidance on whether you have properly classified your workers.

3. Convert to the Employer-Employee Model

Studios are beginning to convert to the employer-employee model as a way to cut-off the accrual of additional liability and to stop worrying about an audit. This is more common for larger studios or studio chains. Some smaller studios are beginning to convert. You should consult with your tax expert, accountant or employment lawyer to get professional guidance if you want to convert.

Avoid Red Flags

Make sure that you do not have any red flags. Some of these red flags are: (i) failing to get invoices from your teachers; (ii) not using professional independent contractor agreements or using “do it yourself” agreements (or none at all); (iii) supervising your teachers; (iii) requiring teachers to follow a studio manual which makes them do odd jobs around the studio and controls the way they teach; (iv) requiring teachers to open and close the studio and collect money from students; (v) paying benefits or business expenses of the teachers; and (vi) not requiring teachers to run independent businesses.

What Should Yoga Teachers Do About The Independent Contractor Problem?

Many yoga teachers think this is not their problem because the studios are liable for properly classifying their workers. However, yoga teachers have an important stake in this issue. If a studio is audited and loses, it may be driven out of business. This devastates the yoga community and you will lose your job. If the studio survives and converts to employer-employee, taxes will be deducted from your paycheck and you will lose your tax deductions for that studio.

Yoga teachers should bring these issues to the attention of the studio owners and encourage them to make intentional, informed decisions as to the business model they wish to follow. If you work at a studio and see the red flags, provide the studio with a copy of this article and encourage it to get professional help.

My Role In This Situation

My intention is to educate the California yoga community about the alarming actions of the EDD and the effect that an audit and potential tax liabilities may have on the viability of yoga studios. I hope to empower you to understand and comply with the tax laws to reduce your chances of tax liability. I want to see yoga studios build strong businesses so they can continue to provide the benefits of yoga.

I am not a member of the California State Bar, I do not specialize in employment law and this letter is not legal advice. I am not soliciting or accepting any legal representation of yoga studios in California on matters involving classification of yoga teachers.

Here is how I can help:

1. You can buy a copy of my book Light on Law For Independent Contractors. It has 200 pages of discussion and resources on both the federal and state law of independent contractors and employees. It has a chapter on California law. It has both the IRS and EDD worksheets to use for classifying workers. It has model independent contractor and employment agreements. Here is the link if you are interested:

http://garykissiah.com/tees/independentcontractors/

2. You can consult with me from a business point of view to discuss your situation and assess the best way forward. I will be happy to provide you with the EDD Information and Worksheet, the Tax Audit Guidelines, the EDD Worksheet and the IRS Guidelines.

3. You can contact me and I will be happy to refer you to a California lawyer who specializes in this area of the law.

I am very sorry to bring these unpleasant developments to you but I have seen the results of these audits and they are heartbreaking. We cannot continue under the conventional view that teachers are independent contractors because “everyone else does it that way.” Both the IRS and the States are auditing businesses nationally over this issue. They view using independent contractors as abusive and want the tax revenues. I view this is a result of the success of yoga. As money has flowed into yoga and the mainstream media has embraced yoga in everything from advertisements to movies, it has caught the attention of the tax collectors and they are following the money. They want our tax revenues.